I Didn't Follow the Rules. My Kids Turned Out Great. Here's What I Actually Did.

A friend said something to me recently that stopped me in my tracks.

"You know what you are?" she said. "You're the poster child for Mel Robbins' 'let it go.'"

She's probably right. I just didn't know that's what I was doing at the time.

I have two kids, a 20-year-old and a 25-year-old. By every measure that actually matters, they turned out great. They're happy. They're hardworking. They're kind, well-socialized, competent young adults whom I genuinely count among my favorite people on earth. We have a relationship built on trust and respect that started the day they were born and gets stronger every year.

And I did it without reading the books, following the experts, or losing a single night of sleep over whether I was doing it right.

What I did instead was simpler. But before I get to that, let me tell you how I got there.

Like most pregnant women, I was immediately buried in parenting magazines and advice the moment I announced I was expecting. I read them through my entire pregnancy and for about the first three weeks of my firstborn's life.

Put them on a schedule. Don't put them on a schedule. Let them cry themselves to sleep. Never let them cry themselves to sleep. Each article was written by a specialist. Each specialist contradicted the last.

I'd finish an article and think to myself, “That will not work for me.”

After three weeks, I put the magazines down and never picked them up again. I followed my instincts instead. That decision, made almost by accident in those exhausted early weeks, turned out to be one of the best parenting decisions I ever made.

I raised my kids on common sense, mutual respect, and one guiding principle that I made no apologies for:

If momma isn’t happy, nobody's happy.

I questioned every rule I was handed. The ones that actually kept my kids safe and supported their well-being? Those stayed. The ones that existed just because society said so, because other parents did it, because that's how I was raised? Those went straight into the trash.

Take curfews. Every parent I knew had a hard curfew, every night, no exceptions, because that's what parents do, and all kids should have one. I looked at that differently. Did my kids need a curfew on a particular night to keep them safe? Then they had one. Was there no real reason for it that night? Then there wasn't one. Simple. Situational. Based on actual reality rather than a rule for the sake of a rule.

My kids learned something from that. They learned that rules exist for reasons, not rituals. They learned that I trusted them enough to think rather than just comply. And they learned that when I did set a boundary, it meant something, because I didn't set boundaries for sport.

 

What I See Now — And Why I Started This Blog

These days, I spend time on the parenting pages and blogs — Grown and Flown, the Facebook groups for parents at my kids’ college — and I cringe.

Not because the parents don't love their kids. They clearly do, desperately. But the dysfunction. The battles. The anxiety. The kids who can't launch, can't cope, can't communicate with their own parents. The families that feel like opposing teams.

And here's the thing I keep thinking: most of those problems didn't start in college. They didn't start in high school. They started much earlier, in small moments that felt insignificant at the time. A rule enforced for no real reason. A boundary set out of fear rather than logic. A child who learned that love came with conditions, or that their parent's anxiety was more important than their own growing independence.

Friends and other parents ask me regularly what my secret is. I've always deflected. I'm not an expert. I have no degrees. I'm not qualified to tell anyone how to raise their kids.

But here's what I've decided: the fact that I'm not an expert might be exactly the point.

Because, with all due respect, the experts are not the ones crushing it. The parents I see struggling the hardest are often the ones who followed all the rules, read all the books, and did everything they were told. And the kids I see thriving, really thriving, often have parents who trusted their gut, stayed calm, and got out of their own way.

That's what Hindsight Parenting is. Not a credentials-based prescription for how to raise your kids. Not another book telling you what the research says.

It's one mom who got it mostly right, looking back with clear eyes, trying to explain what she actually did, and pointing out, as kindly as possible, where she thinks things went wrong for everyone else.

I don't have a psychology degree. I have a 20-year-old and a 25-year-old who call me just to talk.

I'll take that.

 

Welcome to Hindsight Parenting. I'm Michele Hara, and I'm glad you're here.

Previous
Previous

The Tantrum That Never Happened Again